July 8, 2023 | Quebec
An Unexpected Question Can Also Be an Opportunity to Stand Out
You prepared carefully for your interview. You researched the company, reviewed the job posting, and considered the usual questions about your skills, training, and experience. Then the recruiter asks you a question you were not expecting at all.
What should you do?
An unexpected question does not necessarily mean the interview is going badly. It may simply allow the recruiter to learn more about how you think, communicate, or respond to a new situation. Some interviews also include scenarios designed to assess a candidate's abilities and approach to problem-solving.
The goal is not to prepare an answer to every possible question. Instead, it is to learn how to respond when you do not already have an answer prepared.
1. Why Do Recruiters Ask Unexpected Questions?
Interview questions allow employers to assess much more than the information included on a resume. They can help them better understand a candidate's profile, abilities, and motivations.
Some questions focus directly on professional experience. Others may ask you to describe a situation you experienced, explain a decision, or solve a hypothetical problem.
For example:
Tell me about a situation where you had to adapt quickly.
What would you do if you received two urgent requests at the same time?
Tell me about a mistake you made and what you learned from it.
How would you respond if you disagreed with a coworker?
Questions like these can help reveal how you draw on your experiences and skills when responding to a specific situation.
👉 Learn more: How to Succeed in a Job Interview for Your First Job
2. Take a Few Seconds Before Answering
Did a question catch you off guard? You do not have to start talking immediately.
Taking a few seconds to think can give you time to understand the question, choose a relevant example, and organize your answer.
The Government of Quebec recommends taking time to think about your answers and, if you do not understand a question, asking for clarification rather than answering too quickly.
You can tell the interviewer that you would like a moment to think.
That short silence may feel much longer to you than it does to the person conducting the interview. It is generally better to take a few seconds to formulate a structured answer than to begin immediately and lose track of what you want to say.
3. Identify What the Recruiter May Be Assessing
When a question seems unusual, try to determine which skill it may be designed to assess.
A scenario involving several urgent tasks may relate to priority management.
A question about a disagreement with a coworker may assess communication and collaboration.
A question about a past mistake may allow you to demonstrate your ability to acknowledge mistakes, learn, and improve.
A new or unfamiliar situation may require adaptability or problem-solving.
Employers may use interview questions to gather information about the abilities, skills, aptitudes, and experience relevant to the position.
Understanding what a question is trying to uncover can help you choose a much more relevant answer.
👉 Learn more: Understanding Employer Expectations in Quebec
4. Use Concrete Examples
When you are asked how you responded to a particular situation, a concrete example is generally more informative than a broad statement.
Simply saying “I work well under pressure” provides relatively little information.
Explaining how you managed to complete an important project despite an unexpected challenge gives the recruiter more concrete information. Your example does not necessarily need to come from a full-time job. If you are at the beginning of your career, you can draw from different experiences:
- a practicum;
- a student job;
- a project completed during your training;
- volunteer work;
- a team project;
- a relevant personal responsibility.
The important thing is to choose a situation that helps the recruiter understand what you did and what the experience demonstrates about your skills.
👉 Learn more: Identifying and Showcasing Your Practical Skills at the Start of Your Career in Quebec
5. Structure Your Answer When a Question Is Complex
A behavioural question can become much easier to answer when you break your response into parts.
You can describe:
the situation, to provide context;
the task or problem, to explain what needed to be accomplished;
the actions, to describe what you did;
the result, to explain what happened or what you learned.
The goal is not to recite a formula you have memorized. This structure provides a framework that can prevent you from telling a long story without highlighting the most important points.
It can be particularly useful when a question catches you off guard.
6. Think Out Loud When Solving a Problem
Some interviews may include a scenario in which you are asked to solve a problem. The Government of Quebec notes that this type of interview can be used to observe how a candidate responds to a problem or performs under pressure.
In this situation, your reasoning may be just as informative as your final answer.
You can begin by identifying the information you have, determining what is missing, making assumptions, and explaining the steps you would take.
If essential information is missing, you can also ask questions.
This allows you to demonstrate how you approach a problem when the solution is not immediately obvious.
👉 Learn more: How Can You Develop Transferable Skills to Advance Your Career?
7. What Should You Do When You Don't Know the Answer?
Contrary to advice that was sometimes given in the past, you do not need to invent an answer to avoid saying that you do not know.
It depends on the question.
If it is a factual or technical question and you genuinely do not know the answer, avoid improvising information that may be incorrect. You can acknowledge the limits of your knowledge and, when appropriate, explain how you would seek the information or approach a solution.
If you know part of the answer, start with what you know and identify what you would need to verify.
This type of response can demonstrate your reasoning, your ability to recognize the limits of your knowledge, and the way you approach an unfamiliar situation.
8. Ask for Clarification When a Question Isn't Clear
An unexpected question may be ambiguous.
In that situation, asking for clarification is not necessarily a sign of hesitation. The Government of Quebec explicitly recommends asking for an explanation when you do not understand an interview question.
You can ask the recruiter to clarify a particular point or confirm your understanding before answering.
Doing so may prevent you from spending several minutes answering a question the recruiter did not actually ask.
9. Prepare for the Unexpected Without Memorizing Answers
It is, of course, useful to prepare for certain questions before an interview. The Government of Quebec recommends reviewing the job posting, identifying the skills being sought, preparing answers, and practising through mock interviews.
But preparing for an interview does not mean memorizing a script.
A more flexible strategy is to prepare a collection of concrete situations that demonstrate different skills:
- an accomplishment;
- a problem you solved;
- a challenge you overcame;
- a mistake and what you learned from it;
- a teamwork experience;
- an example of taking initiative;
- a situation where you had to learn quickly.
The same experience can sometimes be used to answer several different questions, depending on the angle you take.
This can help you adapt your answer when a question's wording changes.
10. Turn a Difficult Question Into an Opportunity to Demonstrate Your Skills
An unexpected question can be unsettling, particularly if you do not yet have much interview experience.
However, it can also allow you to demonstrate qualities that a perfectly rehearsed answer may reveal less clearly: adaptability, listening skills, communication, judgment, problem-solving, or professional confidence.
The important thing is not to search at all costs for the “perfect” answer.
Listen to the question. Take time to think. Ask for clarification if necessary. Draw on a concrete experience when possible, and explain your reasoning when you are presented with a problem.
After the interview, make a note of the questions you found most difficult. Reviewing those questions and refining your answers are among the ways you can improve your performance in future interviews.
👉 Learn more: Building Your Professional Positioning at the Start of Your Career in Quebec
FAQ
1. Why do recruiters ask unexpected interview questions?
Interview questions can help recruiters learn about a candidate's abilities, skills, motivations, and experiences. Some scenarios can also show how a candidate approaches a problem.
2. What should you do if you don't understand an interview question?
Ask the recruiter to rephrase the question or clarify what they would like to know. Asking for clarification when you do not understand a question is among the Government of Quebec's recommendations for succeeding in an interview.
3. What should you say when you don't know the answer?
Avoid inventing information. Depending on the type of question, you can acknowledge that you do not know the answer, explain what you do know, and describe how you would find the information or approach the problem.
4. How should you answer a behavioural interview question?
Choose a concrete situation and briefly explain the context, the problem or task, the actions you took, and the result. The example should primarily help the recruiter understand how you applied your skills.
5. How can you prepare for unexpected interview questions?
Instead of memorizing dozens of answers, prepare several experiences that demonstrate your skills and practise describing them from different angles. Mock interviews can also help you become more comfortable.
Explore Further
👉 Internships and Entering the Workforce: What You Need to Know
👉 How to Build an Effective Resume at the Start of Your Career
👉 How to Write an Effective Cover Letter for Your Job Search