ad
Back To Top

Make or Buy: How Does This Decision Affect Supply Chain Management?

July 12, 2023 | Quebec

Understanding Why an Organization May Need to Choose Between Handling an Activity Internally or Turning to a Supplier

Before even choosing a supplier, an organization may face a fundamental question: should it produce a good or perform an activity internally, or is it better to turn to an external source?

 

This question, often referred to as a make-or-buy decision, can directly influence a supply chain strategy. It involves comparing different options while considering the organization's needs, costs, and available resources.

 

In CDI College's Supply Chain Management – LCA.FL program, the make-or-buy decision is introduced in the Supply Chain Management I course as part of purchasing strategy. It is also explored in the context of international sourcing.

 

What Does Make or Buy Mean?

The principle involves two options.

 

Make means that the organization chooses to carry out an activity or produce what it needs internally.

 

Buying means choosing to obtain the good or service from an external source. 

 

The question may seem straightforward, but the decision does not necessarily come down to comparing an internal cost with a supplier's price.

 

The program situates this decision within the broader context of purchasing strategy, helping students understand that it can occur before several other decisions in the supply chain.

 

Why Does This Decision Come Before Supplier Selection?

Before searching for and evaluating suppliers, an organization must first determine whether it actually wants to obtain what it needs from an external source.

 

The make-or-buy decision can therefore influence what happens next.

 

If the organization decides to buy, it may then need to define its need, identify potential sources of supply, and establish the conditions for evaluating the available options.

 

The program covers areas such as translating a need into purchasing requirements, sourcing, supplier qualification, and the relationship between quality, cost, and delivery time.

 

The make-or-buy decision is therefore an upstream decision that can determine whether an external purchasing process needs to begin.

 

👉 Learn more: Defining a Need in Supply Chain Management: A Key Step in the Process

 

Why Are Costs Important in This Analysis?

Comparing two options requires an understanding of the costs associated with each one.

 

The Introduction to Cost and Management Accounting course covers areas such as fixed and variable costs, direct and indirect costs, budgets, break-even analysis, and financial analysis.

 

These concepts help explain why a comparison based solely on a supplier's quoted price would be incomplete.

 

An activity performed internally also requires resources. Conversely, purchasing from an external source may involve additional costs beyond the amount shown in a supplier's offer.

 

The program also covers the total cost of ownership, expanding the analysis beyond the initial purchase price.

 

A make-or-buy decision may therefore require a more detailed examination of the costs associated with each option.

 

👉 Learn more: Total Cost of Ownership: Why Doesn't the Purchase Price Tell the Whole Story?

 

Is Price the Only Factor to Consider?

No. The curriculum does not present supply chain decisions as choices based exclusively on price.

 

The Supply Chain Management I course covers quality, costs, and delivery times, as well as the identification and evaluation of supply sources.

 

These dimensions broaden the analysis.

 

One option may appear attractive from a financial perspective while presenting other characteristics that also need to be considered in the decision.

 

The question, therefore, becomes less about "Which option costs the least?" and more about "Which option best meets the organization's needs and established criteria?"

 

What Role Do Internal Resources Play?

Choosing to make something means the organization must be able to carry out the activity using its own resources.

 

The decision, therefore, needs to be considered in the context of the organization and the need it is trying to meet.

 

The curriculum does not provide a specific list of internal resources that should be analyzed as part of a make-or-buy decision. It would therefore go beyond the program content to present such a list as though it were a method taught in the program.

 

However, the curriculum does connect this decision to purchasing strategy, costs, and the definition of the need.

 

This approach demonstrates why an option cannot be evaluated independently of the capabilities and objectives of the organization that will use it.

 

What Happens When an Organization Decides to Buy?

Choosing an external solution can lead to several activities associated with supply chain management.

 

The organization may need to identify suppliers, establish criteria, evaluate available options, and negotiate specific terms.

 

The program also covers various types of contracts, requests for quotations, calls for tenders, and other mechanisms for structuring purchasing activities.

 

The "buy" option, therefore, involves more than simply purchasing something externally.

 

It entails a process in which the organization must define its requirements and determine how it will select an external solution.

 

How Does the Decision Change in an International Context?

The make-or-buy decision is also covered in the International Business and Trade course.

 

The curriculum connects it with international sourcing strategy and reshoring.

 

This perspective adds a geographic dimension to the decision.

 

When an organization considers different sources, the decision may involve international markets. The program then introduces other considerations, including country, geopolitical, and transactional risks, foreign currencies, and international sales contracts.

 

Choosing an external source may therefore need to be considered within a much broader context than simply comparing two suppliers.

 

A Decision That Can Shape the Supply Chain Strategy

The make-or-buy decision brings together several skills covered in CDI College's Supply Chain Management – LCA.FL program.

 

It requires an understanding of the need, an examination of costs, and, when appropriate, consideration of purchasing strategy before moving on to identifying and evaluating suppliers.

 

Most importantly, it demonstrates that supply chain management does not always begin with the question "Which supplier should we choose?"

 

In some cases, another question needs to come first: "Should we obtain this solution from an external source?"

 

Understanding this step helps illustrate how an upstream decision can shape the supply chain activities that follow.

 

FAQ

1. What does make or buy mean in supply chain management?
It refers to determining whether an organization will carry out an activity or meet a need internally or turn to an external source. The program covers this decision as part of the purchasing strategy.

 

2. Is a make-or-buy decision based only on costs?
No. Costs are one part of the analysis, but the program also covers quality, delivery times, needs, and supply chain strategy. These considerations help place the decision within a broader context.

 

3. Can a make-or-buy decision involve international sourcing?
Yes. It is also covered in the International Business and Trade course in connection with international sourcing strategy and reshoring.

 

Explore Further

👉 Supply Chain Management: Understanding the Field and Career Opportunities

 

👉 Supplier Evaluation: What Criteria Should You Consider in Supply Chain Management?

 

👉 International Sourcing: What Risks Should You Consider?

 

👉 Learn More About CDI College's Supply Chain Management – LCA.FL Program

Would you like to get more information or apply?

Info Banner Background Image